Penn Jillette on Celebrity Apprentice: "If There Were Rules, I Would Have Cheated"
Ahead of the Celebrity Apprentice Season 12 premiere (NBC, February 12, 2012), Penn Jillette talked about why you can't cheat at an arbitrary game, what he learned watching people abandon their mor…
From the Vault · 2012
This is an archival piece from the Premier Guide Miami collection. The coverage, context, and details reflect the time it was originally published.
I saw people who were willing to do anything to win — they had let go of their morality completely — and they still didn't win. — Penn Jillette
Premier Guide Miami Exclusive Interview
Penn Jillette said it plainly: "I saw people who were willing to do anything to win — they had let go of their morality completely — and they still didn…" — and Premier Guide Miami was in the room when it happened.
On January 4, 2012, NBC held a press call for Celebrity Apprentice Season 12, premiering Sunday, February 12th at 9 p.m. on NBC. Four contestants joined the call: Adam Carolla, Lou Ferrigno, Penn Jillette, and Aubrey O'Day. Premier Guide Miami was among the outlets on the call.
I saw people who were willing to do anything to win — they had let go of their morality completely — and they still didn't win. It's like a guy who decides to rob a liquor store with a shotgun and everybody looks at him and goes, get out of here. He's already done the moral transgression and he still failed at his task.
Why you can't cheat at Celebrity Apprentice
Asked why he didn't simply use mind games or magic to win, Jillette went straight to the philosophy: "Because no one knows what game you're playing. It's an arbitrary game without rules. I cannot tell you the rules of Celebrity Apprentice — it's an arbitrary, capricious thing. So if there aren't rules, you can't cheat. If there were rules, I would have cheated." He did, however, put his skills to use: "It turns out I did do magic, I did do juggling, I did do fire eating. But in terms of mind games it was mostly just being in a tiger cage and numb."
On morality, strategy, and Mike Tyson
Jillette's framework for the game came from an unlikely philosopher: "My plan was actually from Mike Tyson, who said everyone has a plan until they get hit. And everybody does have a plan until they get hit. And the instant that something doesn't go the way you planned — especially with this particular group of people — all plans go out the window." What depressed him most was watching people abandon their ethics for nothing: "I believe that what is a little bit depressing about working on the show is that even people who suspend their morality completely and are willing to do anything don't do it well enough to do damage. I saw people who were willing to do anything to win — you could see clearly that they had let go of their morality completely — and they still didn't win. It's like a guy who decides to rob a liquor store with a shotgun and everybody looks at him and goes, get out of here. He's already done the moral transgression and he still failed at his task."
Love Miami covers the city's conversations — the interviews, the creative voices, the tastemakers and innovators who define South Florida's cultural identity. This is the pillar where Miami speaks for itself.
The Elvis charity — and why he was fighting for it
Jillette's charity was Opportunity Village, a Las Vegas organization supporting intellectually disabled adults — but his reason for choosing it was pure Elvis: "My charity was Opportunity Village. It's a real important paradigm — a new way of thinking about getting people back into the culture. But all of that is just the intellectual justification. The real reason in my heart is that it was an Elvis charity. All those scarves that Elvis gave out from the stage were made at Opportunity Village. Every time Elvis kissed one of those scarves and threw them out into the audience, that was something made by Opportunity Village. So I was on Celebrity Apprentice fighting for the charity that Elvis Aaron Presley would have fought for."
On reality TV, the Loud Family, and watching people act worse on camera
Jillette came to the show as a genuine outsider to the genre: "Unlike the other people, I don't watch these shows. It's just not part of my schedule. I had never really seen a reality show." But he had a theory he wanted to test: "Since the Loud Family in 1971, when PBS kind of invented this format, they found out that people did not act better on camera than they would in regular life — but rather acted worse on camera, which is a fascinating thing. And I wanted to kind of see it. It's really nutty to feel that as opposed to just watching it. It's really funny to see people that you know acting unpleasantly just because there are TV cameras on." On what Celebrity Apprentice actually is: "What you're seeing on shows like Celebrity Apprentice is not any sort of documentary — you're seeing an improvised soap opera by professionals." Celebrity Apprentice Season 12 premiered Sunday, February 12, 2012, on NBC.
For more upcoming events across South Florida, visit the Premier Guide Miami Events Calendar .
The PGM Edit
Penn Jillette on celebrity apprentice — this is the kind of conversation Premier Guide Miami was built to have. Follow us for more Love Miami.
Premier Guide Miami
The Live · Love · Play Dial
Veterans Day Ceremonies Across Miami-Dade: Coral Gables, Hialeah, Doral, North Miami, and Pinecrest — All Free, All November 11
Miami Beach Veterans Day Parade Steps Off at 11:10 AM — Ocean Drive, Military Flyover, Free and Open to All
Spain Brings Its Travel Tech Innovators to Miami for the Spain–US Smart Tourism Forum — November 9–10
Gale Miami Unveils The Fifth — A 40,000-Square-Foot Event Destination Hits Miami on November 17
The Dance Party That Ends Before Bedtime Is Coming to Fort Lauderdale — Earlybirds Club Hits Revolution on November 21
Atlantic Village's Holiday Edit Brings Holiday Shopping, Pilates, Facial Massages, and Live Music to Hallandale Beach on November 14
How to Beat Art Week Traffic in Miami Beach: Free Water Taxis, Shuttles, Park-and-Ride Garages & Causeway Rules
Navigating Miami Beach during Art Week comes down to one rule: ditch the car before crossing the bay. With FDOT lane reductions slowing westbound traffic on the MacArthur Causeway, the City of Miami Beach has rolled out free water taxis, dedicated fair shuttles, and extended midnight trolley service.
Sheroanawe Hakihiiwe Brings Over 100 Works to ICA Miami for His First U.S. Museum Solo Exhibition
ICA Miami presents the first U.S. museum solo exhibition of Venezuelan Yanomami artist Sheroanawe Hakihiiwe, with over 100 works spanning drawing, printmaking, and works on paper that preserve ancestral botanical and ecological memory. Free admission. 61 NE 41st Street, Miami Design District.
Three New Public Art Installations Turn Lincoln Road Into a Free Open-Air Gallery Ahead of Art Week
Three newly unveiled outdoor installations on Lincoln Road Mall give locals and visitors museum-grade sculpture without needing a fair pass. The zero-ticket walk connects South Beach's most trafficked pedestrian corridor to Art Week's broader cultural footprint.
Creative R&D on the Fair Floor: Zach Lieberman, Google Arts & Culture, and Hans Ulrich Obrist Lead Art Basel Conversations
The December 4 Conversations panel at the Miami Beach Convention Center brings Hans Ulrich Obrist, artist-engineer Xin Liu, creative coder Zach Lieberman, and Google Arts & Culture's Amit Sood and Freya Salway together to unpack how artist-led labs and AI/creative R&D are reshaping studio practice.
Independent.
·Unsponsored.
·Always Free.
Premier Guide Miami has never accepted payment for editorial coverage. Our story →