Donald Trump on Celebrity Apprentice Season 12: Firing Debbie Gibson and Dee Snider, Dayana's Underrated Brilliance, and Why Good Television Isn't Always Good Business
On April 3, 2012, Premier Guide Miami joined a press conference call for Celebrity Apprentice Season 12. Host Donald Trump reflected on two of his hardest firings of the season — Debbie Gibson and Dee Snider — and made the case that the show's most underrated contestant was Dayana Mendoza.
From the Vault · 2012
This is an archival piece from the Premier Guide Miami collection. The coverage, context, and details reflect the time it was originally published.
Donald Trump said it plainly: "Two people I would hire would be these two, believe me in a second. Sometimes good television isn't necessarily the peop…" — and Premier Guide Miami was in the room when it happened.
On April 3, 2012, NBC held a press conference call for Celebrity Apprentice Season 12 following the firing of Debbie Gibson and Dee Snider. Host and executive producer Donald Trump joined both contestants on the call. Premier Guide Miami's Daedrian McNaughton was on the line. This piece focuses on Trump's exchanges — on the difficulty of these particular firings, his defense of Dayana Mendoza, and the distinction he drew between what makes great television and what makes a great hire.
Two people I would hire would be these two, believe me in a second. Sometimes good television isn't necessarily the people you'd hire.
On the difficulty of firing Debbie and Dee
Trump was unusually candid about how hard these two firings were. "People think I enjoy firing people. I don't. In the two cases here, that was a hard — to me it was very hard. There have been contestants where I didn't even think about it. It was easy to fire, whether I didn't like them or it was so obvious. This was a very hard one for me, because I like them, and it was also not obvious." He acknowledged that both could have fought differently and possibly survived: "I also knew they could've done things differently and possibly lived to fight another day, but they chose for very good reasons — for nice reasons they chose not to. And I respected that. I understood that when I was doing it."
On Dee Snider specifically — and being too much of a gentleman
Trump singled out Dee Snider's decision not to attack Lou Ferrigno as the pivot point: "I actually wondered why didn't he hit Lou harder? And I think Dee probably realizes — I'm not sure that Dee would've changed because he's a quality person. So I'm not saying he did the wrong thing, but he could've been a winner. And he is a winner." Snider's response: "Thank you." Trump: "Being a gentleman sometimes isn't always a good thing." Snider: "No. It means I'm sitting home watching the show."
On Dayana Mendoza — the most underrated person on the show
Love Miami covers the city's conversations — the interviews, the creative voices, the tastemakers and innovators who define South Florida's cultural identity. This is the pillar where Miami speaks for itself.
Trump was emphatic about Dayana Mendoza's treatment by the women's team: "I happen to think Dayana is probably the most underrated person on the program. I think she's actually very smart, and she can kill you with the eyes and the look and the stare and all. I just don't get it. They just go after her one after another." He added: "She's also very beautiful by the way, in case you haven't noticed." Both Debbie Gibson and Dee Snider agreed — Snider noted that when Dayana joined the men's team, he and Penn Jillette couldn't understand what the women's problem was.
On good television vs. good business
When the conversation turned to whether the boardroom's combative style reflected real business, Trump was direct: "That is true by the way. Sometimes good television isn't necessarily what — these are not necessarily the people that you'd hire. Two people I would hire would be these two, believe me in a second." He added that he had been at Debbie Gibson's Broadway opening twenty years earlier and had always been a fan of Dee Snider's music. "They're two great people. Yes, these are two people that you'd really hire."
On what's coming — and Aubrey O'Day
Asked about the Arsenio Hall–Aubrey O'Day conflict, Trump declined to weigh in on whether Arsenio's frustrations were warranted — but he promised the season was only getting started: "Stay tuned, because what you saw the other night is nothing compared to what happens between them and a couple of others. It is the toughest we've ever had on the Apprentice/Celebrity Apprentice. What happens in the next couple of weeks you won't even believe." He called it "amazing television." Dee Snider's summary of Aubrey: "She's horrible. She's evil." Celebrity Apprentice airs Sundays at 9 p.m. Eastern on NBC.
For more upcoming events across South Florida, visit the Premier Guide Miami Events Calendar .
The PGM Edit
Donald Trump on celebrity apprentice season 12 — this is the kind of conversation Premier Guide Miami was built to have. Follow us for more Love Miami.
Premier Guide Miami
The Live · Love · Play Dial
Brightline's Buzzer Beater Is Back for the Miami Heat Season — Skip the Traffic, Catch the Game
Brightline's game-day train service returns for the 2026–27 Miami Heat season, connecting fans from Orlando, West Palm Beach, Boca Raton, Fort Lauderdale, and Aventura to MiamiCentral Station — a 15-minute walk from Kaseya Center. The Heat open at home October 21 against the Timberwolves.
Trump Tower Punta del Este: Eric Trump Unveils Uruguay's Newest Luxury Address
On August 8, 2013, Premier Guide Miami was invited to an afternoon cocktail with Eric Trump at Trump Hollywood to discuss the launch of Trump Tower Punta del Este luxury residences in Uruguay.
Major Lazer Is Headlining Faena's Art Basel Music Series — and Chase Sapphire Reserve Cardholders Get a Private Dinner
The Faena Art Music Series returns December 2 with Major Lazer headlining and Richie Hell opening. Chase Sapphire Reserve cardholders get access to a private sunset cocktail hour, an exclusive dinner called 'Transatlantic Express: A Shared Table,' and a VIP area. Tickets go on sale October 27.
You're the Jury: This Interactive Courtroom Show at the Manuel Artime Theater Puts You in the Deliberation Room
The Jury Experience — a 60-minute live theatrical show by Fever where the audience becomes the jury — is running at the Manuel Artime Theater in Miami through the end of the year. No two performances are the same because the room decides the verdict.
Independent.
·Unsponsored.
·Always Free.
Premier Guide Miami has never accepted payment for editorial coverage. Our story →